Personal Opinion – The Men We Carry in Our Minds – Best Sample Essays(2022)
This article covers a Personal opinion essay about “The Men We Carry in Our Minds”.
Permalink: https://privateessaywriters.com/personal-opinion
As you follow along, remember that our qualified writers are always ready to help in any of your nursing assignments. All you need to do is place an order with us! (Personal opinion)
Option 1: Personal Opinion
Scott Russell Sanders’s essay “The Men We Carry in Our Minds” emphasizes how work and economic class affect the ways that a person understands gender. Silvia Federici’s argument, in “Wages Against Housework,” centers on how definitions of womanhood keep all women down, but especially those in the working class.
For this essay, answer the following questions. As you answer, provide evidence from your observations and experiences to support your claims:
…
Solution
Personal opinion – The Men We Carry in Our Minds
Work and economic class have an impact on how people understand and describe gender. All cultures have created gender differentiating definitions regarding what work is for men and what is for women. There are substantial distinctions that have proven difficult to eradicate. In some cultures, men who undertake work perceived to be for women are considered weak. The link between work, social status, and gender are prehistorical (Padavic & Reskin, 2002). However, the distinctions are becoming less significant in the current times due to the changing cultural norms, religious and intellectual transformation, technological advancement, and economic institutions.
The gender differentiation in workplaces determines how particular tasks are assigned and valued. Normally, those higher status tasks are for men, and tasks such as being a clerk or a secretary are for women. Women’s work is less valued than men’s work, even if it takes the same amount of time, skill, and effort (Wiesner-Hanks, 2020). Women have always complained about pay inequalities for the same jobs as men.
Interestingly, the work definition is mostly gender-biased as men’s tasks are considered “work,” while women’s roles are perceived as “helping.” Although the current situation is immensely different as more men and women take roles perceived to be of the other gender, society still does not consider women-perceived tasks such as housework as “work.”
The social construction of gender has played a significant part in creating noticeable differences between males and females strikingly similar in biological terms. Societies create and maintain gender distinctions with consequences. The sexual division of labor, however, varies across time and countries. Despite the tremendous changes towards creating a status quo, women are more likely to take on specific jobs such as food serving, and men similarly are more likely to choose more physical jobs such as machine operations when given a choice. Society still believes specific roles make a man more manly and a woman more womanly.
Some jobs, such as blacksmiths and bricklayers, have remained exclusively for men in many parts of the world, and the changes are prolonged. This social construction has led to some women believing they are incapable of performing complex and physical tasks. Prehistorically, men have held more esteemed positions that give them a special economic and social status over women (Wiesner-Hanks, 2020).
The devaluation of women’s work is embedded deeply within major religions and societies of the world. This devaluation has consequences such as the gender pay gap, as the more female occupation is, the fewer wages for men and women working in that occupation.
Scott Russell Sanders’ essay gives in-depth analysis and more support for this opinion. Sanders explains how he grew to envy women and their place in society. As a boy, he believed that women’s tasks were more luxurious and they had broader options of what they wanted to do, either go work in the church, the library, or at home catering for the baby. He explains that as a boy, he would have preferred to cater to the baby given a choice. Men had limited options to be a factory worker or a soldier.
The essay addresses past and current gender issues and problems. The author also describes the troubles that exist across economic statuses. Sanders grew in a society where men had more troubles and struggled more than women, and he grew predicting his fate to either become a soldier or a factory worker. Sanders’ perceptions of women’s lifestyle as pleasant changed when interacting more with women from different societies.
He explains that he was slow to comprehend the troubles women face, and he never understood women’s feelings to be everything in society. Sanders believes that women in the current society have more pressure around the workplace than men.
Sanders faced criticism in college from girls who wanted to share in the glory of wealthier jobs. Sanders defends his former opinion since these girls did not know his background and assumed he would be like their fathers. Sanders’ interaction with women and girls from wealthier societies gave him insights about women’s troubles (Sanders, 1987). This essay shows the variation in gender differentiation across cultures and societies and the troubles both men and women face regarding labor’s sexual division.
As you continue reading, remember that our top and qualified writers are here to help with any of your assignments . All you need to do is place an order with us.(Personal opinion)
Sanders’ essay and Silvia Federici’s argument covers most aspects of work and gender, especially those related to gender-specific responsibilities, economic status, and gender value for work (Federici, 1975; Sanders, 1987). However, they do not address race-related gender issues, earnings, access to productive inputs and resources, time use, and men’s troubles in the current situation. The authors have focused more on the social construction of gender responsibilities, what work is for men, and what work is for women, and both genders’ troubles.
However, the author talks more about “women” work and not work, which would offer a broader spectrum of other gender-related issues in the workplace. Race plays a major part in gender inequalities, as women in different cultures are valued differently. European cultures have not experienced much of gender issues at the workplace than the United States, African, and Asian countries. The authors also do not address the troubles and graces of men and women working in the same occupation.
The world, especially the US, has experienced the gender pay gap problem due to gender valuation of work. There is also no information about time use and productivity, as women in many societies are regarded as less productive as they spend more time in roles of lower value. The world is experiencing a higher unemployment rate among men than women. The authors have also not addressed this issue and supporting circumstances. These aspects are more current, and less information about them is available in both authors’ works.
References
Federici, S. (1975). Wages against housework. Bristol: Falling Wall Press.
Padavic, I., & Reskin, B. F. (2002). Women and men at work. Pine Forge Press.
Sanders, S. R. (1987). The men we carry in our minds. The Writer’s Presence, 828-832.
Wiesner-Hanks, M. E. (2020). GENDER AND WORK.
Question
Option 1: Personal Opinion
Scott Russell Sanders’s essay “The Men We Carry in Our Minds” emphasizes how work and economic class affect the ways that a person understands gender. Silvia Federici’s argument, in “Wages Against Housework,” centers on how definitions of womanhood keep all women down, but especially those in the working class.
For this essay, answer the following questions. As you answer, provide evidence from your observations and experiences to support your claims:
1. Do you believe work and economic class affect the ways that people understand gender? If so, how?
2. Which of the two authors best supports your belief and why?
3. What aspects of work and gender do you believe neither author addresses? Why do you think they overlook these aspects?
Essays must be 3-4 pages in length, double spaced and in 12-point font. Please submit essays in either PDF or Word Document format.
Option 2: Analysis
Scott Russell Sanders’s essay “The Men We Carry in Our Minds” discusses the ways in which the author believes that the working class men of his childhood suffer through a life of toil and struggle, while the wives of these men engage in labor that is less physically demanding. Meanwhile, in “Wages Against Housework” Silvia Federici criticizes and attacks the ways in which certain types of labor come to appear as though they are natural attributes of women.
For this essay, please examine how Federici and Sanders each discuss the concepts of gender, class and work by answering the following questions:
· How do these two authors attempt to transform their own identities in relation to these three categories?
· What effect does this transformation have on the types of work each author is expected to perform?
· Finally, drawing on your own observations and experience, what relevance do their arguments have for us today?
Essays must be 3-4 pages in length, double spaced and in 12-point font. Please submit essays in either
PDF or Word Document format.
Option 3: Critical Comparison
Scott Russell Sanders’s essay “The Men We Carry in Our Minds” discusses the ways in which the author believes that the working class men of his childhood suffer through a life of toil and struggle, while the wives of these men engage in labor that is less physically demanding.
Meanwhile, in “Wages Against Housework” Silvia Federici criticizes and attacks the ways in which certain types of labor come to appear as though they are natural attributes of men and women.
Your task is to place Federici in conversation with Scott Russell Sanders by summarizing the main points of each author. Explore how one essay might account for what the other has ignored or left out. Following this, explore how you think concepts of gender are changing today. Has this change been the result of anything either author mentions?
Essays must be 3-4 pages in length, double spaced and in 12-point font. Please submit essays in either PDF or Word Document format.